Insulation Guide

Insulation Types Compared

Quick comparison: For most above-grade walls, fiberglass or mineral wool batt provides the best R-value per dollar. For attics, blown cellulose is typically the most cost-effective. For basements and air-critical applications, spray foam provides the best combination of R-value and air sealing. Rigid foam board is the go-to for continuous exterior insulation.

Side-by-Side Comparison

ProductR/inchAir Barrier?Vapor Retarder?Best ForRelative Cost
Fiberglass battR-3.14–R-4.3NoNo (kraft facing adds minor)Walls, floors$
Mineral wool battR-3.7–R-4.2NoNoWalls, fire-rated assemblies$$
Blown celluloseR-3.5–R-3.7NoNoAttics, retrofit walls$
Blown fiberglassR-2.2–R-2.7NoNoAttics$
Open-cell spray foamR-3.5–R-3.8Yes (3.5″+)NoWalls, attic deck$$$
Closed-cell spray foamR-6.0–R-7.0Yes (1″+)Yes (2″+)Basements, roofs, exterior$$$$
XPS rigid foam boardR-5.0Depends on installationYes (Class II)Exterior CI, basement$$
Polyisocyanurate (polyiso)R-5.5–R-6.5Depends on installationDepends on facingExterior CI, above-grade$$
EPS rigid foam boardR-3.6 to R-4.0Depends on installationClass III onlyBelow-grade, exterior CI$

Fiberglass Batt

The most widely used insulation product in North America. Available in pre-cut widths for 16″ and 24″ o.c. framing, and in standard depths for 2×4 (R-13, R-15) and 2×6 (R-19, R-20, R-21) cavities. Installation is simple for owner-builders. The primary limitations are that it provides no air sealing (requires separate air barrier) and performs poorly when compressed, wet, or installed with gaps around obstructions.

Mineral Wool (Rock Wool / Stone Wool)

Produced from basalt or recycled slag, mineral wool batts provide similar R-values to fiberglass with several advantages:

Cost is typically 2–3× fiberglass batt. In fire-rated assemblies, code-required wall applications, or assemblies needing acoustic performance, mineral wool’s premium is usually justified.

Blown Cellulose

Produced from recycled newsprint and treated with boric acid for fire resistance. The most common attic insulation for upgrades to existing homes. Key advantages:

For attic retrofits, blown cellulose installed to 13–14 inches achieves R-49, and about 16–17 inches reaches the R-60 that IECC 2021 requires in Zones 4–8. For wall retrofit (dense-pack), cellulose is blown through small holes drilled in the exterior sheathing at each stud bay.

Rigid Foam Board

Three main types, each with different chemistry and applications:

Polyiso cold-temperature caution: Polyiso’s R-value degrades below 25°F. In a Zone 6–7 climate, the exterior foam sees temperatures well below this, so the effective R-value in service is lower than the labeled R-value. Many building scientists recommend using XPS or EPS for exterior CI in cold climates, where the labeled R-value is stable at all service temperatures.

Choosing by Application

ApplicationBest ProductWhy
2×6 exterior wall, new constructionR-20 or R-21 batt (fiberglass or mineral wool), plus R-5 exterior CI in Zones 4–8Best R per dollar; simple installation
2×4 wall, code upgrade (Zones 3+)R-13 batt + R-5 exterior CI (Zone 3) or R-10 CI (Zones 4–8)Most cost-effective code-compliant path
Attic, new installationBlown cellulose or blown fiberglassFast, economical, can be layered
Basement wallClosed-cell foam (2″) + batt stud wallMoisture resistance + vapor control
Crawl space (sealed)Closed-cell foam or EPS on wallsMoisture resistance at grade
Rim joist2″ closed-cell spray foamAir seal + vapor retarder in one step
Exterior CI over sheathingXPS or EPS (cold climates), polyiso (warm)Stable R-value at all service temperatures
Unvented roof deckClosed-cell foam (per IECC Table R806.5)Keeps deck above dew point

Build Your Wall Assembly

Compare insulation types layer by layer and check IECC 2021 compliance for your climate zone.

Open R-Value Calculator →

Frequently Asked Questions

What insulation has the highest R-value per inch?

Closed-cell spray foam at R-6.0 to R-7.0 per inch is the highest R-value per inch of any commonly available residential insulation. Polyisocyanurate rigid foam is close behind at R-5.5 to R-6.5 per inch (but degrades in cold temperatures).

Is cellulose or fiberglass better for attic insulation?

Blown cellulose provides higher R-value per inch (R-3.5 to R-3.7) than blown fiberglass (R-2.2 to R-2.7), meaning you need less depth for the same R-value. Cellulose also settles less proportionally. Blown fiberglass installs faster and does not settle as much as cellulose in some loose-fill applications.

What is the difference between EPS, XPS, and polyiso rigid foam?

EPS (expanded): R-3.6 to R-4.0/inch, lowest cost, vapor-permeable, suitable below-grade. XPS (extruded): R-5/inch, moisture-resistant, vapor retarder, stable R-value in cold. Polyiso: R-5.5 to R-6.5/inch, highest R, degrades in cold (use for exterior CI only in warm climates or inside the thermal envelope).

Can I mix insulation types in the same wall?

Yes. Combining products is common and often code-required: R-13 batt in the stud cavity with R-5 XPS on the exterior is a standard code-compliant wall assembly. Spray foam on the rim joist combined with batt in the walls is another common combination. Products must be compatible for fire rating purposes — exposed foam insulation requires a thermal barrier (drywall) in habitable spaces.

Related Articles